Should I Paint or Replace My Interior Doors?
Interior doors don’t usually get much attention… That is, until they start looking worn, squeaky, or out of style. Then suddenly, they’re impossible to ignore. If you’re a homeowner wondering whether it’s time for a fresh coat of paint or a full-on replacement, the good news is both options have their merits. The best choice really depends on your door’s condition, your design goals, and of course, your budget.
Let’s walk through when painting makes sense, when replacing is the smarter move, and how to weigh the costs of each option.
When Painting Interior Doors Is a Good Idea
Sometimes, all your door needs is a little facelift. And painting is one of the simplest and most affordable ways to do it. If the door is structurally sound, a professional paint job can hide years of wear and bring it back to life.
The Door Is Structurally Sound
If your door still opens, closes, and latches properly, there’s no need to toss it. Minor surface flaws like scuffs, fading, or an outdated stain color are easy to fix with the right prep and paint. A well-executed paint job can make even a decades-old door look brand new.
You’re Updating the Room’s Color Scheme
Maybe you’re remodeling your bedroom with a modern palette, or you’ve jumped on the trend of darker, moodier interiors. A coat of paint can instantly update your doors to match your new style. From crisp white to bold navy, paint opens up endless design possibilities without the hassle of replacing the entire unit.
When Replacing the Door Makes More Sense
Sometimes, paint just isn’t enough. If your door is warped, cracked, or no longer fits the frame properly, replacement is usually the smarter (and less frustrating) choice. Older homes in Oregon often have hollow-core doors that don’t do much for insulation or noise reduction. Swapping those for solid-core or paneled designs can add both function and style.
Replacement also makes sense during bigger renovation projects, when upgrading the trim, hardware, and style all at once creates a cohesive look.
Comparing the Costs of Painting vs. Replacing Doors
Money often tips the scales in the paint-or-replace debate. Painting is almost always the less expensive option upfront, but replacement can be a better long-term investment if the door is in poor condition.
Cost to Repaint Interior Doors
For Oregon homeowners, professional painting typically might cost several hundred dollars per door, depending on prep needs and whether both sides are being painted. Hiring pros ensures the paint is applied evenly, edges are clean, and the finish holds up for years. While DIY might save a little money, uneven brush marks or skipped prep can lead to peeling or chipping down the road.
Cost to Replace Interior Doors
Now, let's talk about replacement. Replacing an interior door is a bigger investment. A basic hollow-core slab door runs about $50 to $100, while solid-core or decorative panel doors can range from $150 to $400 each. Add in hardware, hinges, and professional installation, and the total can land between $200–$500+ per door. It’s more expensive than painting, but sometimes replacement is the only way to get a sturdier, better-functioning door.
Tips for Painting Interior Doors Like a Pro
Painting a door may sound simple: you grab a brush, swipe on some color, and call it a day. But anyone who’s ended up with streaky brush marks, stuck-on hardware, or paint drips knows it’s trickier than it looks. Doors are high-traffic surfaces that get touched, pushed, and slammed daily, so a sloppy job shows fast. The key to a professional-looking finish is not just the paint but the preparation and technique.
Here are a few tried-and-true steps the pros never skip.
- Remove hardware: so paint does not drip on knobs or hinges.
- Sand the surface: lightly to smooth imperfections and help paint adhere.
- Use primer: if you are switching from a dark stain to a lighter paint.
- Choose the right finish: such as semi-gloss or satin for durability and easy cleaning.
- Apply thin, even coats: with high-quality brushes or sprayers for a streak-free look.
While it’s possible to DIY, professional painters have the tools, skills, and efficiency to achieve flawless results, without you spending your weekend covered in paint speckles.
Popular Interior Door Trends in Oregon Homes
In the Willamette Valley, homeowners are giving doors more design attention than ever. Some of the top trends include:
- Shaker-style panels: Simple, clean lines that suit both modern and traditional homes.
- Crisp white with black hardware: A timeless combo that adds contrast and elegance.
- Bold accent colors: Deep greens, charcoal, or even muted pastels that make a door pop as a statement piece.
- Rustic finishes: Stained wood tones that complement farmhouse and craftsman-style homes.
Why Fitzpatrick Painting & Construction Is a Trusted Choice
When it comes to painting interior doors (or replacing them when needed), Fitzpatrick Painting & Construction brings decades of expertise to Oregon homes. With a full-time staff, over 1,000 verified reviews, and a reputation for detailed craftsmanship, we know how to transform doors into durable, stylish features that enhance your home’s look. Whether you’re after a budget-friendly refresh or a total style upgrade, our team delivers results you’ll be proud of.
Frequently Asked Questions About Interior Door Updates
Q: What should I consider before repainting an interior door?
A: Check the condition of the door. If it’s solid, painting is usually a great option.
Q: Do painted doors last as long as new ones?
A: A properly painted door can last years, but if the door is structurally weak, replacement is the better option.
Q: Can Fitzpatrick Painting replace my interior doors if needed?
A: Yes, we handle both painting and replacement.
Q: What kind of paint finish is best for interior doors?
A: Semi-gloss or satin finishes are durable, easy to clean, and resist fingerprints.
